Every couple weeks or so, we send out a little roundup of new recipes, techniques, and tutorials that we’ve recently posted on the site. Occasionally we announce exclusive giveaways to newsletter subscribers as well. We won’t spam you with ads or share or sell your email address. Every email we send has a 1-click unsubscribe link if you decide it’s not for you.
Sourdough Technique Experiment: No Knead vs. The Works
My love of baking comes from experimenting with different techniques and ingredients and, of course, eating the bread. In terms of experimenting, so many factors influence the creation of a great loaf of sourdough bread: wheat and flour type, hydration, autolysis, stretching and folding, fermentation time and temperature, shaping, scoring, proofing, baking vessel, oven temperature and more.
An experiment I recently decided to do was to use Breadtopia’s Select Bread Flour a.k.a. “the Holy Grail of bread flour,” and hold all these variables constant except for autolysis and stretching and folding, in order to assess how much these activities actually impact the final product. I picked these variables to test, because they are somewhat time-consuming. They can intimidate new bakers and prevent people from baking during the work week. (There are two-plus hours of stretching and folding in most Tartine style sourdough recipes.)
I baked two loaves of bread using identical ingredients and weights, fermentation time and temperature, loaf shape and scoring pattern, baking vessel and oven. The only variations were that one loaf, called “S&F,” had an autolyse stage, and the dough was stretched and folded four times after the leaven and salt were added. The other loaf, “No Knead,” was mixed when the leaven and salt were added to the S&F loaf. Nothing was done to No Knead until the end of the bulk fermentation, when both doughs were preshaped, benched, shaped, proofed and baked in the same manner.
After cooling, I evaluated the loaves from the outside and inside (oven spring, crust, crumb), and compared their flavor.
My results were surprising. There was almost no difference in the final loaves; they were remarkably similar in shape, height, and crumb. A few slices show S&F being taller, but a few slices show No Knead with a more open crumb. A tie.
The oven spring of S&F had slightly wider and smoother openings in the crust, but I can’t be sure if this was from the autolyse and stretching and folding, or from inconsistent scoring depth on my part.
Also, the crust of the S&F appeared a little more carmelized, a deeper brown, but this difference might have stemmed from experiment-design flaws as well: the position of the boules in the oven or a different proofing basket/bowl. For 8.5 hours in the refrigerator, one boule proofed on a tea towel in a banneton with air flow, and the other on a tea towel in a glass bowl (more airtight). The lighter-colored No Knead loaf was in the glass bowl and had very little flour on it when I flipped it into the dutch oven. The S&F loaf was in the banneton, and it retained more tea-towel flour after the proof (perhaps was dryer because of air flow) and baked a darker crust under the excess flour.
In terms of flavor, I couldn’t detect a difference in the loaves, despite the 4-hour autolyse, which should have been long enough for any mellowing or enhancement of flavor to have occurred. My experiment did not have multiple taste testers, though, and I could lack the nuanced palate needed to pick up on a difference in the flavor.
During this experiment, I noted some differences in dough texture and handling. Although I added the starter at the same time to both doughs, the S&F dough started to develop bubbles earlier. However, a few hours in, the No Knead was also quite bubbly. The doughs at the end of the bulk fermentation still looked different, with S&F’s surface being bubbly but smoother, while No Knead had one large popped bubble and a rougher looking texture. Similarly when stretching out the doughs for preshaping, S&F was easier to manipulate. Though by the time the bench rest was over, they felt similar for shaping.
My conclusion from this experiment is that you should bake even if you don’t have time for the stages of autolysis and stretching and folding. For the sake of dough handling and perhaps modest improvements in crust, these stages are beneficial, but the general look and flavor of the breads were similar.
Ultimately, this experiment was limited in scope, though, and there are many opportunities for further study. I used a flour that is high in gluten, a long fermentation time (15% starter), and one hydration level (74% water). A difference in any of these factors or others could mean that autolysis and stretching and folding have a more dramatic impact on the final loaf.
For example, if these loaves were made from a flour with less gluten and more starter, autolysis and stretching and folding might lead to markedly better gluten development…or the opposite (see below).
Higher Hydration: I made a third loaf of this bread a couple of days later with 82% hydration. I didn’t autolyse the dough, and I stretched and folded the dough twice. Basically, I aimed for a halfway point in baking technique and upped the hydration. The loaf was flatter and the crumb more open.
Different Wheat: I repeated the entire experiment methodology using all whole grain einkorn flour several weeks later. The doughs were 70% hydration and 28% starter i.e. a faster ferment on a grain known for its low gluten formation abilities. As with the experiment described above, one dough was autolysed and stretched and folded four times; the other was mixed all at once and left untouched until the end of the bulk fermentation. In this experiment, the No Knead loaf was by far the winner. It spread less during the bench rest and the final loaf had more height and oven spring. So it would appear that in the case of whole grain einkorn wheat, extra handling harmed gluten formation.
See the Gallery below the recipe for photos of the bread from the original experiment, the high hydration bread, and the results of the einkorn of the experiment.
Sourdough Technique Experiment: No Knead vs. The Works
Experimenting with different baking techniques can yield surprising results. In this case, Breadtopia Select Bolted Organic Bread Flour performed as well with the no knead technique as it did with more elaborate gluten developing steps.
Ingredients
Instructions
No Knead
The Works
Preshape
Shopping List
Sourdough Technique Experiment: No Knead vs. The Works